
Sunset, San Giorgio, Venice (American Art Museum); Artist: William Gedney Bunce
I have already started planning the recipes I want to make during the holidays.
I had such a long list of pies, I decided to make one last weekend.
I made an apple pie with apple cider caramel sauce. I can’t remember how I came to learn about the recipe — I think someone somewhere said that it was legend in their family to I sought it out.
The technique for both making the caramel and assembling the pie were vague.
For the pie – I made my standard which is basically the Betty Crocker apple pie with the Serious Eats Easy Pie Dough. Okay — well, when I went to link to the Betty Crocker classic, it doesn’t resemble what I do.
I use half Granny Smith and half Braeburn or Honeycrisp. I peel and slice and after I slice I give them a good squish of lemon juice and stir through the apples. I use 1 t. cinnamon and 1/2-3/4 cup of granulated sugar and 1/4 c flour to thicken — I try to let it sit for at least an hour – but that’s not a requirement. Pre-heat the oven to 425. Put some foil on the shelf underneath to catch dripping. I overfill my pies and I know they are done when they drip. Rim the edges with foil or a pie shield. Bob gave me one like this. Bake 25 minutes at 425. Remove shield and then 30-35 minutes at 375.
If you’re going to make this and can’t follow these instructions — drop me a note and I’ll explain it better.
So I made my standard pie recipe except reduced the sugar to 1/4 cup.
I used my vague caramel instructions to try to find a better recipe.
Can we all sit here and hold hands and mourn how terrible it is to try to find things online?
Moving on. I read several apple cider caramel sauce recipes and did what I felt was right. The recipe suggested layering apples and caramel but I made a layer of apples to cover the bottom and then mixed the caramel into the apples and filled.

The pie turned out gorgeous golden brown and was so bubbly. I need to clean my oven – even with the foil.
Not layering the caramel was a tactical error. I was so worried about it being a sugar bomb — but if you bit into a caramel pocket it was so good. I also was kinda stingy with the caramel and put the leftover in the fridge.
The second time we ate it — I put the sauce on the table and we drizzled it on the pie. It was *amazing.* And not too sweet.

